Martin Lefebvre
Hi, everyone. Thank you for tuning in to our NBI podcast series on the state of the markets and the economy. In today's session, we're asking: after the U.S. midterm elections, what are the opportunities for the Canadian market? To help me navigate the subject, I'm joined by Macan Nia, Investment Strategist at PICTON Investments. Macan, welcome.
Macan Nia
Thank you and thank you for having me.
Martin Lefebvre
Let's start with the opportunities you're seeing in the markets. With the midterm elections behind us, which were historic in the way things turned out, we were expecting a sweep, but it was more than we had anticipated. What types of opportunities do you see emerging for Canadian investors?
Macan Nia
Yes, I think the extent of the election results surprised many people. It's another reminder that consumers vote with their wallets, and we saw that clear as day. With the sweep and a divided government, historically, market returns have been above average, and we've seen that. What made this election interesting from a Canadian perspective is that a Democratic Congress has historically taken a more multilateral approach to trade. It likely reduces the probability of further tariff escalation. If anything, it potentially creates a backdrop for resolving the tariff conflict. I look no further than the states that went from Republican to Democratic as a sign of that: Ohio, Illinois, Michigan and Pennsylvania. These are among the states most vulnerable to the tariff fallout we've experienced over the past couple of years. For example, in Pennsylvania, 25% of the state's exports come to Canada. They have been under considerable pressure. Looking at the election results, Ohio flipped a Senate seat from Republican to Democratic. In Michigan, Democrat Dr. Abu Abdullah Syed won over Mike Rogers. In Pennsylvania, the Democrats achieved a trifecta for the first time since 1993. From a Canadian investment perspective, I think it's positive, and we'll talk more about the specifics. There are winners and losers from election night. At PICTON, we believe Canada and the provinces are potential winners because of a likely better environment for resolving these trade disputes.
Martin Lefebvre
Trump has mostly used decrees to steer the economy. Do you really think that's going to change? What sort of leeway or leverage does he still have in this kind of political gridlock?
Macan Nia
Yes. Well, there will be more pressure from his - not his followers per se, but Republicans in Congress. With a split government, there may have to be more compromise between the Trump administration and Congress. You're right: election-night politics are one thing; the reality of governing is another. But at the margin, from a Canadian perspective, is it going to be easier or more difficult to reach a resolution, whether on tariffs or other issues? From our point of view, it's likely to be better going forward, given the makeup of Congress.
Martin Lefebvre
Looking across the Canadian market, which sectors or industries do you feel are best positioned for the environment we're in?
Macan Nia
As my wife says, I talk too much, but let me take a step back and look at the big picture. Over the past couple of years, Canada has been viewed as a geopolitically stable, fiscally credible alternative to some international markets. Look no further than the Canadian Investment Summit held in September of this year. There were $100 trillion in assets represented in one room, which is incredible to think about. The goal is for Canada to attract close to a trillion dollars in new investment over the next five years. When it comes to our pension funds, there is also a focus on bringing home some of the capital they've been investing outside Canada. A couple of years ago, the OECD [Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development] measured pension plans' median allocation to domestic investments. That figure is roughly 60%. Let's be clear: there are significant differences at either end of the range. Türkiye, for example, invests close to 90% within its own economy. The Latvian pension plan invests 20%, while Canada invests only 12%. This has shrunk dramatically from roughly 75% just two decades ago. From a big-picture perspective, if these factors lead to more capital being invested in Canada, that will help the Canadian economy and certain sectors, such as energy and materials. Utilities might benefit from the AI build-out, which we can discuss. Financials, which make up more than a third of our index, will also benefit. Looking more closely, at PICTION, we see three major factors that position the Canadian economy and the TSX favourably over the next couple of years. The first is the commodity cycle. Historically, long periods of underinvestment are followed by upcycles. That mismatch should benefit Canada. The second is energy security. Look at what has happened over the past five years, whether it's the conflict in Eastern Europe or what's unfolding in the Middle East. Countries are increasingly looking for sustainable, predictable energy flows, which should help Canada. Last but not least is artificial intelligence. Everyone listening is well aware of the extraordinary capital investment taking place in the U.S. Interestingly, Martin, a possible by-product of what's unfolded in the U.S. is the situation in Texas, which no one predicted would go Democratic across the board in its state government. To your earlier point, I don't think AI data centres will stop being built in Texas. There may be a few more questions, but that positions Canada very well. If one of these data centre providers wants to move north of the border, it can go to Saskatchewan or Alberta. We have access to energy and a colder climate, which is beneficial. That should also help Canada. From a big-picture perspective, these three elements favour Canada over the next couple of years.
Martin Lefebvre
We've talked about the Democratic sweep, the blue wave, tariffs and the opportunities in Canada. But what about Canada–U.S. relations? Do you think Trump has less leverage than he used to? There are only two years remaining in his mandate. How do you see Canada–U.S. relations evolving, and what are the opportunities for investors?
Macan Nia
Martin, you're asking me an impossible question: trying to get into the mind of an individual south of the border. But let's try anyway. I think what is true today can be very different tomorrow. I think at the margin, there will be more of an effort, whether it's from the top of the house, but more so again, people will have to be governing not for the next two years, but for the next four, the next eight. Most people recognize that a strong Canada–U.S. relationship is essential. Looking at history and around the world, no two other countries have had such a close, enduring relationship. We are partners. I think this is just a blip on the radar, not an indication of where our relationship is heading. That said, I think the relationship is going to improve. Going back to those three factors, politics matters, but so does the policy that comes from it. Some forces are bigger than politics and policy and compel them to change or adapt. Take the commodity cycle and copper, for example. We've had decades of underinvestment in supply, and an enormous amount of time and capital is now being put into bringing production online. Martin, you don't even need heroic assumptions about demand growth to be constructive on copper. We always ask how this plays out. I've been in the business for two decades, and we go through these cycles. It's human nature: commodity companies generate enormous cash flows and have an incentive to invest them. By the time they invest and production actually comes on stream, we're into the next cycle. When you look at copper, it takes 10 to 20 years to build a world-class facility. Oil is the same. Right now, the gap is being filled by using recycled copper. Production is 22 million tonnes, and demand is 27 million tonnes. The global economy has been able to bridge that gap by using recycled copper. As we move towards 2030, demand will be higher, so we'll need more copper production. Energy is another example. Given what's happening in Qatar and the Strait of Hormuz, Canada is being viewed as an opportunity. As I mentioned earlier, provinces such as Saskatchewan and Alberta have abundant, low-cost energy resources that can support artificial intelligence, and this is happening. I don't think any of us would dispute that AI will be part of our lives going forward. There will be questions about company valuations and how much they're spending on capital expenditures. To put the scale of this investment into perspective for listeners, AI investment represents 2.1% of U.S. GDP [Gross Domestic Product]. That's hard for me to visualize. What does it mean? Martin, about a year ago, I was in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, of all places, and people were protesting Meta's Hyperion data centre. That may have been the canary in the coal mine. I looked into it: the initial investment was $50 billion, and it's expected to reach as much as $200 billion. This is one data centre, and it will be Meta's largest, covering the equivalent of 3,000 football fields. I've been to games, but what does 3,000? For those of us who've been to New York, that's equivalent to four times the size of Central Park.
Martin Lefebvre
It's something like seven kilometres long, which is incredible to think about.
Macan Nia
I worked out the Montreal equivalent: about 14 Mount Royal Parks for one data centre. Imagine the amount of raw materials, copper and cement, and the number of people needed, including electricians and plumbers. This is not going away. The question is how it will affect stocks. Again, who should benefit? Canada should benefit.
Martin Lefebvre
If I understand you correctly, you're saying that even though Carney is stepping up efforts to reach other partners, the ease of doing business with the U.S. will probably return over the next couple of years, right?
Macan Nia
I believe, I don't think it's a bad idea. We talk to our clients about diversifying their investments; as Canadians, it's also a good idea to diversify our customer base. I know he wants to increase trade with China by 50%. Those numbers are still very small compared with our trade with our largest partner, the U.S. So I agree with you: it's about diversification. But our relationship is strong in so many ways. We share a border, and that's not going away anytime soon.
Martin Lefebvre
Yes, it's also about maintaining our independence and sending the right message south of the border. All right, let's bring this back to the investor's perspective. We usually say that growth has been in the U.S. market, whether through economic growth or the rapidly expanding AI industry taking the lead, while Canada has often taken a back seat in investors' minds. But as Canadian investors, we know that combining both markets can create an all-weather portfolio: Canada's industrials, banks and commodities alongside the U.S. market. What is the stronger case for potentially overweighting Canada today? Why Canada, and why now?
Macan Nia
Yes, that's a good way of putting it: a well-diversified, all-weather portfolio. What's the case for Canada? Including this year, we've seen a couple of years of TSX performance. Can it continue? We've looked back over the past 50 years, and these periods of outperformance aren't one-offs. They don't last just one or two years; they can be long-lasting. Go back to the 1980s, when the U.S. outperformed Canada for more than 15 years. Volcker came in and brought inflation under control, Reagan (administration) introduced tax cuts, and demographics provided significant tailwinds. Then came the dot-com collapse in 2000. Over the next decade, the TSX outperformed the S&P 500 in eight out of ten years. That was driven by one major theme: China growing at 8% and building cities with populations of one million and ten million. All of that required our raw materials. A commodity boom. Exactly. Then came the next decade, with AI. Are we now entering a new phase where—and again, at PICTON, we are strong believers in AI—concentration risk is becoming a more important consideration? Are global investors starting to look at Canada through a different lens? We're all trying to understand which sectors and companies AI will affect. As you mentioned earlier, Canada has hard assets. They call it HALO: hard assets, low obsolescence. Whether we're talking about commodities or energy, these assets are hard to replace. AI isn't going to replace a copper mine, and uranium deposits won't be changed by a new algorithm created in Silicon Valley. Investors may be thinking: I have concentration risk in the U.S., and my U.S. weighting has increased. Perhaps now is a good time to rebalance, realize some of those gains and reinvest in the TSX, with its greater exposure to hard assets with low obsolescence. We have a government that, at the margin, currently seems pro-investment. On top of that, consider valuations. We know market-cap-weighted valuations are at elevated levels; I wouldn't want to call them extreme. Despite the TSX's performance over the past couple of years, it is still trading at a 25% discount to the U.S. Canada has historically traded at a discount, but not this wide. For all those reasons, at PICTON, we believe the Canadian investment story hasn't fully played out. There is still an opportunity. Returning to a well-diversified portfolio, it may be worth increasing Canadian weightings, which, as with the CPP (Investments), have declined over the years compared with a couple of decades ago.
Martin Lefebvre
Macan, in closing, what recommendations do you have for investors listening today?
Macan Nia
My recommendations depend on the audience. For clients, it's to turn off the news. I've spoken to a few clients who looked at their statements and said, ‘Macan, I'm surprised.’ Yes, the wall of worry has been steep. Given how turbulent 2026 has been, it's surprising. The Greenland headlines were this year, though they seem like years ago.
Martin Lefebvre
So were the headlines about the 51st state.
Macan Nia
Yes, that seemed like years ago. Every year is full of headlines, but this year seems especially so. For clients, that's why you work with an advisor: to navigate these situations. When you sit down with your advisor, you're not planning for just the next year, but for five, ten or twenty years. So, for clients, turn off the headlines. For advisors, consider the three factors I discussed: the commodity cycle, energy and AI. It's not any one of these factors in isolation; it's that they're working together. That creates a very powerful backdrop. Another point for investors concerns asset allocation. The traditional 60/40 portfolio has worked since the 1980s because those forces worked together. But 2022 reminded us that, in an inflationary environment, those correlations may not be as favourable as we once thought. At PICTION, as an alternative investment firm, we think this is important, and we're seeing increased allocations to alternatives. If you're worried about a growth scare, stocks and bonds should work as they have historically. But what happens if there's an inflation scare? I'm not saying we'll see another 2022, but inflation could be higher than we've been used to. Last week's CPI [Consumer Price Index] report was hotter than expected. The inflation measures we follow don't point to an environment of declining inflation. When considering investment opportunities, we tend to focus on stocks and bonds and the choices within them. But what about adding another component: alternatives alongside stocks and bonds that could help us navigate an inflationary environment more effectively? Interestingly, I think it was last week that the CPP (investments), our largest pension plan—not a hedge fund—with, I believe, close to $900 billion in assets, said it wanted to double its allocation to these alternative strategies. I think the plan is to increase it from about $80 billion to $160 billion over the next five to seven years. The world is always changing, and we seem to be in an environment where inflation will not be what it was before 2020. Adding an allocation to alternatives is one way to help protect our clients and navigate this volatility and changing environment.
Martin Lefebvre
Well, Macan, that was very insightful. That's all the time we have today. To everyone watching, thank you. Please stay in touch, and we'll talk again next month.